It's fast, easy, and you'll get a great price. Plus, there's no pressure — we'll buy your car even if you don't buy one from us.

Fast payments

Get an accurate online appraisal or stop by. Either way, you’ll have your cash in about 2 days.

Simple process

Selling privately is a hassle and a huge time commitment. Make it easy on yourself and make a deal with us.

Fair, honest pricing

Get the right price for your vehicle. You can sell to us with confidence because we stand behind all of our quotes.

Sell Your Car in Indianapolis, IN — Get a Top Dollar Offer at Fishers Imports

Whether you're upgrading your vehicle, downsizing, or simply ready to move on, Fishers Imports makes it easy to sell your car in Indianapolis and across central Indiana. We pay top dollar for all makes and models — sedans, SUVs, trucks, and luxury vehicles — and you don't have to buy from us to get a competitive offer. Get an instant online appraisal or bring your vehicle to either of our Indianapolis-area locations and walk out with cash in as little as 2 days.

Vehicle Information1 / 4

Get started by entering your Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) or make and model.

History & Condition2 / 4
Photos (Optional)3 / 4
Contact Information4 / 4
Estimated Offer5 / 4

Why Sell Your Car to Fishers Imports Instead of Privately?

Private sales can take weeks and come with real risks — lowball offers, no-shows, and the hassle of handling all the paperwork yourself. Here's why Indianapolis sellers choose us:

  1. We buy all makes and models — luxury, non-luxury, any mileage, any condition
  2. No obligation to buy — you can sell your car to us without purchasing another vehicle
  3. Same-day appraisals — walk in at either location during business hours, no appointment needed
  4. Firm offers we stand behind — no last-minute price drops after inspection
  5. Payment in as little as 2 days — faster than any private buyer, with none of the risk
  6. Indiana's largest pre-owned luxury dealer — over 12,000 vehicles purchased and sold, we know the market

At Fishers Imports, honest pricing isn't a tagline — it's how we operate. Our appraisers evaluate your vehicle based on real-time market data, current demand for your make and model, mileage, condition, and service history. You'll receive a transparent offer with a clear breakdown of how we arrived at the number. We stand behind every quote we make.

If you're selling a luxury vehicle — BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Lexus, Audi, Porsche, Cadillac, or Land Rover — our team has specific experience appraising high-end pre-owned vehicles and understanding what they're actually worth in the Indianapolis market. We're not guessing. We're buying hundreds of vehicles a year and we price accordingly.

What You'll Need to Sell Your Car in Indiana

Indiana has straightforward requirements for selling a vehicle to a dealership. To make your appointment as smooth as possible, bring the following:

  1. Your vehicle title — or lien holder payoff information if you still owe on the loan
  2. A valid government-issued photo ID (driver's license or passport)
  3. Your vehicle registration
  4. Any service or maintenance records you have available — documented history can increase your offer
  5. All keys and key fobs for the vehicle

If your title has a lien, don't worry — our team handles that process regularly and will walk you through the payoff steps. You don't need to resolve it before coming in.

Serving Indianapolis, Fishers, Carmel, and All of Central Indiana

Both Fishers Imports locations are conveniently located for sellers across the Indianapolis metro. Our Fishers location at East 126th Street serves buyers and sellers from Noblesville, Carmel, Westfield, and Zionsville. Our Northwest Indianapolis location on West 96th Street is easy to reach from downtown Indianapolis, Avon, Plainfield, and Brownsburg. Wherever you are in central Indiana, selling your car to Fishers Imports is a short drive to a fast, fair offer.

Frequently Asked Questions About Selling Your Car at Fishers Imports

Do I have to buy a car from Fishers Imports to sell mine?

Not at all — we make competitive cash offers regardless of whether you purchase from us. Here's what to expect:

  1. Same-day appraisal at either location
  2. A firm offer with no pressure to buy
  3. Payment in as little as 2 business days

We buy all makes and models, luxury or otherwise, no strings attached.

What do I need to bring to sell my car in Indiana?

To sell your car at Fishers Imports, bring the following:

  1. Your vehicle title or lien payoff information
  2. A valid photo ID
  3. Your current vehicle registration
  4. Service records if available — they can increase your offer
  5. All keys and remotes

If your title has a lien, our team handles that process regularly and will guide you through it.

How long does it take to sell my car at Fishers Imports?

The appraisal itself typically takes under an hour at either location — no appointment needed. Once you accept the offer, here's the general timeline:

  1. Same-day offer after in-person inspection
  2. Title and paperwork processed same day or next day
  3. Payment issued within 1–2 business days

It's one of the fastest ways to sell a car in Indianapolis without the risk of a private sale.

Will Fishers Imports buy my car if I still owe money on it?

Yes — we regularly purchase vehicles with outstanding loan balances. Here's how it works:

  1. Positive equity (car worth more than you owe) — the difference is paid to you
  2. Negative equity (you owe more than the car is worth) — our team will walk you through your options

Bring your current payoff amount or lender information and we'll handle the rest.

Does Fishers Imports buy luxury vehicles?

Yes — and it's one of our specialties. As Indiana's largest pre-owned luxury dealership, we actively purchase:

  1. BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Audi, Porsche, and Land Rover
  2. Lexus, Cadillac, Maserati, and Genesis
  3. Any luxury make or model regardless of mileage

Our appraisers understand the real market value of high-end vehicles and price accordingly — not with a generic trade-in formula.

Is it better to sell my car to a dealer or privately in Indianapolis?

It depends on your priorities. Private sales can yield more on paper but come with real downsides:

  1. Weeks of listings, showings, and negotiations
  2. Risk of no-shows, scams, and unsafe encounters
  3. Full sales tax on your next vehicle purchase if you sell separately

Selling to Fishers Imports is faster, safer, and — when combined with Indiana's trade-in tax credit — often more financially advantageous than it looks at first glance.